The preliminary 2025–26 federal school directory marks 1,187 public schools as closed. When we traced them back to 2019, a pattern stood out: the typical traditional public school on that list had lost 18.6% of its K–12 students before it closed, about three times the decline at schools that stayed open.

Closures are back on school-board agendas across the country. Cleveland, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Houston, Pittsburgh, and Austin have all voted to close groups of schools since late 2025, and St. Louis and Portland are weighing more. For a family choosing a neighborhood or a school, a closure can mean a new building, a new commute, and new classmates in the middle of a child’s time there.

Nobody can predict exactly which school a board will close. But federal enrollment records show what closed schools tended to look like beforehand, and that gives families a few concrete things to check. This analysis joins three National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) files: K–12 membership in fall 2019, K–12 membership in fall 2024, and each school’s operational status in the 2025–26 directory.

Why closures are rising now

American public schools have fewer students than they did before the pandemic. NCES counts 50.8 million students in fall 2019 and 49.4 million in fall 2024. The loss is not spread evenly: many districts are down far more, while growing suburbs and charter networks have added students.

Three pressures are behind the decline:

A district’s costs do not fall at the same rate as its enrollment. A building that is half full still needs heat, maintenance, a principal, and an office staff. Once temporary federal pandemic relief money ran out, many boards began looking at consolidation. K-12 Dive’s closure tracker lists recent votes including 29 schools in Cleveland, 17 in Philadelphia, 17 in Tulsa (effective 2027–28), 16 in Atlanta, and 12 each in Houston and Pittsburgh.

What closed schools looked like beforehand

Of the 1,187 schools marked closed in the 2025–26 directory, 800 still reported students in fall 2024, for a combined 176,083 students. Many of the rest were already empty or were administrative records. We compared the K–12 enrollment of each closed school in fall 2019 and fall 2024 with the same change at schools that remain open, using only schools with at least 100 K–12 students in 2019.

GroupSchools comparedMedian K–12 change, 2019 to 2024Share that lost 20% or moreMedian K–12 enrollment, 2024
Traditional public schools marked closed423−18.6%46.1%240
Charter schools marked closed88−34.7%67%202
Traditional public schools still open74,172−6.1%14.5%446

The difference is large. 46.1% of the closed traditional schools had lost at least a fifth of their K–12 students since 2019, compared with 14.5% of traditional schools still open. The closed schools were also smaller: a median of 240 K–12 students in their final year, compared with 446 at open schools. Closed charter schools had shrunk even more sharply, with a median loss of 34.7%.

Size and decline are rarely the whole story. Boards also weigh building condition and repair costs, how full nearby schools are, transportation, program locations, and community input. A small school that is stable, in good repair, or the only school for many miles faces different decisions from a half-empty building close to another school with space.

The enrollment drop is moving up through the grades

Smaller groups of children enter kindergarten first, then move through elementary school, middle school, and high school over the following years. The national grade counts in the same NCES school files show this happening.

GradeFall 2019Fall 2024Change
Kindergarten3,712,3953,473,714−6.4%
Grade 13,643,6173,412,665−6.3%
Grade 53,795,9483,619,433−4.7%
Grade 63,889,6483,614,574−7.1%
Grade 83,855,5353,696,344−4.1%
Grade 94,033,5063,963,108−1.7%
Grade 123,598,2523,779,169+5%

Fall 2024 had about 305,000 fewer kindergartners than twelfth graders. Among elementary schools that remain open, kindergarten enrollment fell 8.2% between 2019 and 2024. The decline has already reached middle schools, and high schools are next.

School levelOpen schools comparedTotal K–12 changeMedian school changeShare that lost 20% or more
Elementary47,491−6.1%−6.5%16%
Middle14,413−8.6%−8.5%17.1%
High15,876−0.9%−2%7.6%

Middle schools show the steepest decline so far. High schools are close to flat because larger groups born before 2008 are still enrolled there. The Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education projects that U.S. high school graduates will peak around 2025 and then decline. A family buying a home near a full high school today should not assume it will stay full for the next decade.

City schools are the most likely to be shrinking

The decline affects every type of community, but it is sharpest in cities. Among open regular schools, more than one in five city schools has lost at least 20% of its K–12 students since 2019.

LocaleOpen schools comparedTotal K–12 changeMedian school changeShare that lost 20% or more
City22,725−5.9%−7.7%21.1%
Suburb25,905−4.2%−5.4%12.5%
Town8,937−4.1%−5.3%10.9%
Rural22,189−2.5%−4.6%11.3%

City districts often have many buildings close together, so consolidating two half-full schools is easier than in a rural area where the nearest alternative may be an hour away by bus. That is one reason city closures make more news, even though rural schools are smaller on average.

Charter schools tell a different story. As a group, open charter schools gained 9.3% in K–12 enrollment while traditional public schools lost 5.3%. Even so, 14.3% of individual charter schools shrank by 20% or more. A 2025 national study of closures from 2014–15 to 2023–24 found that charter schools closed at a higher annual rate than traditional public schools (2.8% compared with 0.8%). A growing sector does not protect a particular charter school.

How every state compares

The table shows the share of each state’s open regular schools that have lost at least 20% of their K–12 students since fall 2019, along with the state’s total change across those same schools. States are sorted by the share of shrinking schools.

StateOpen schools comparedShare that lost 20% or moreMedian school changeTotal K–12 change
New Mexico65329.4%−11.1%−9.7%
Nevada56928.3%−12.4%−9.7%
Arizona1,58325%−10%−7.6%
Oregon1,10223%−9.8%−8.5%
Alaska29822.1%−7.9%−0.7%
Colorado1,49420.1%−7.4%−5.1%
Louisiana1,15719.2%−6.9%−5.1%
West Virginia56919.2%−10%−8.3%
Texas7,44218.1%−5.6%−3.7%
Utah87817.8%−6.5%−4.6%
New York4,42717.5%−7.1%−6.6%
Washington1,77717.4%−6.9%−6.3%
California8,30917%−7.6%−6.4%
Florida3,20616.7%−5.8%−3.5%
Mississippi79816.7%−6.3%−5.6%
Idaho57016.1%−6.2%−3.7%
District of Columbia20114.9%+0.5%+4%
Delaware18614.5%−4%−2.9%
Montana37914.5%−5.9%−4.9%
Hawaii28113.9%−8%−8.7%
Minnesota1,46613.1%−3.9%−4%
South Carolina1,07013.1%−4.3%−1.8%
Missouri1,88112.8%−5.4%−4.6%
Wisconsin1,75512.8%−5.5%−4.3%
Ohio3,10412.7%−6.3%−3.6%
Kansas1,09712.2%−5.5%−4.6%
Oklahoma1,45412.2%−3.8%+1.4%
North Carolina2,43712%−5.4%−3.6%
Wyoming24112%−6.3%−5.1%
Arkansas94411.7%−4.7%−2.3%
Illinois3,53311.7%−5%−4.2%
Alabama1,28611.5%−3.1%−2.1%
Georgia2,15211.5%−4.3%−2.8%
Michigan2,70911.5%−6.5%−5.1%
Kentucky1,13211.3%−5.4%−4.6%
Pennsylvania2,73311.2%−5.4%−2.7%
Tennessee1,60911.2%−3.8%−3.4%
Iowa1,15810.9%−4.2%−3.6%
Maryland1,28210.8%−4.4%−3%
Nebraska73910.7%−3.4%−4.2%
Maine43910.3%−5.7%−5.7%
Vermont21410.3%−6.5%−5.7%
Indiana1,71110.2%−4.4%−3%
Massachusetts1,5649.6%−4.2%−3.4%
Rhode Island2749.5%−5.5%−5.4%
Virginia1,7699.3%−5.1%−4.3%
South Dakota3179.1%−2.2%−2.4%
Connecticut9189%−5.2%−4.5%
New Hampshire3918.4%−7.8%−7.4%
North Dakota2928.2%+0.1%−0.8%
New Jersey2,2096.4%−0.3%+0.9%

Read this table as a measure of how widespread the decline is, not as a closure forecast. Statewide totals can hide a lot. A state can grow overall because of a few fast-growing suburbs while many of its city and rural schools shrink. States also differ in how they assign school identifiers when programs move or merge, which can affect which schools are matched across years.

What happens to students when a school closes

Research on closures points in one direction: the school a student moves to matters most.

  • After Chicago closed 47 elementary schools in 2013, displacing nearly 12,000 students, the University of Chicago Consortium on School Research found academic effects that were “neutral at best, and negative in some instances.” Displaced students remained about two months behind in math four years later, and students already at the receiving schools lost about one and a half months in reading during the first year.
  • A Michigan study found no lasting harm on average, and gains for students who moved from low-performing schools to stronger ones.
  • A 2024 study of Texas closures found that test scores recovered within about three years, but behavior problems persisted and students had lower college attainment, employment, and earnings at ages 25 to 27. The effects were larger for secondary-school students.
  • A national CREDO analysis, reviewed here by the National Education Policy Center, found that students did worse when they moved to schools that performed no better than the ones that closed.

For families, this means the most useful closure question is often not “will my school close?” but “if it does, where would my child go, and is that school a better fit?”

How to check a school before you commit

  1. Look at several years of enrollment, not one. Use your state education agency’s enrollment reports, the district’s enrollment dashboard, or the NCES ElSi table generator to see each fall count since 2019. A steady multi-year decline matters more than one bad year. Our school profiles show a 2021–22 civil-rights count that excludes pre-K, so compare it only with other K–12 counts.
  2. Compare enrollment with building capacity. Ask the district for the school’s utilization rate (enrolled students divided by building capacity). The Center on Reinventing Public Education notes that districts commonly treat less than 80% of capacity as low utilization.
  3. Find the facilities plan. Search the district site for a facilities master plan, long-range plan, “rightsizing” study, or demographer’s enrollment projection. Closures almost always appear in these documents months before a vote.
  4. Read recent board agendas. Search agendas and minutes for “consolidation,” “boundary,” “co-location,” “repurposing,” and the school’s name. Many states and districts require public hearings before a school can be closed.
  5. Check the district’s budget situation. A projected deficit, a failed levy or bond, or expensive deferred maintenance makes consolidation more likely.
  6. Ask about moratoriums and timelines. Some districts have paused closures for a set period. Chicago’s pause ends after 2026–27, and Denver’s superintendent has said closures could resume.
  7. Identify the likely receiving school. If a closure seems possible, find out which school would take its students and compare the two using the same measures you would use for any school.

Use our school search to find a school and nearby alternatives, then compare up to four schools side by side. Bring your enrollment and facilities questions to a visit with our school visit checklist.

What this analysis cannot tell you

A closure is a decision about buildings and budgets, not a rating of teaching quality. Many schools on the closed list had dedicated staff and strong programs. A growing school is not automatically a better school, and a shrinking school can still be an excellent choice.

The 2025–26 directory is preliminary, and “closed” is how a state reported a record’s operational status. Some entries reflect mergers, moves, or reorganizations where the program continues under a new identifier. Other closures announced for June 2026 or later will not appear until the 2026–27 directory. A school can also close because of a building problem or a charter decision that has nothing to do with enrollment.

Federal enrollment counts are a snapshot taken around October 1. They do not show mid-year changes, and states differ in how they assign students in virtual or shared programs. Percentages for small schools can swing widely with only a few students, which is why we exclude schools that had fewer than 100 K–12 students in 2019.

How we calculated these figures

We used NCES Common Core of Data school membership files for 2019–20 and 2024–25, keeping only the 50 states and the District of Columbia. For each school we added the kindergarten through grade 12 subtotals and excluded pre-K, ungraded, and adult-education counts. Pre-K reporting has changed over time, and including it would make some elementary schools appear to grow. We then joined each school by its NCES identifier to its operational status in the preliminary 2025–26 directory.

“Still open” means a regular school not marked closed, inactive, or future in the 2025–26 directory that reported 2024–25 membership. Percentage changes include only schools with at least 100 K–12 students in fall 2019. Level and locale come from the matching profiles on this site. National grade totals add up school-level records, so they can differ slightly from the official NCES national totals, which also include students reported only at the district or state level. Our analysis script is part of the site’s code, and the summary recalculates from the official files.

Sources and next steps